Wednesday, July 30, 2008

Screenwriting 101: A Character Exercise

Coming up with scenes for a movie isn’t hard. What’s much more difficult is understanding the Big Picture: What is the major conflict of the movie and how does it get resolved? I think that’s my own major weakness. I’ve been thinking about this problem for 30 years, and only now am I beginning to see the solution, which has to do with this “existential story conflict” I’ve been talking about. How do we study this further?

I am not a believer in formal education, but the theory of education has some merit, even if we are educating ourselves. Education isn’t just absorbing facts but engaging in practical low-cost exercises. When you go to school, the teachers give you project assignments, which are theoretically modeled after problems you will encounter in real life. With such academic exercises, you have an opportunity to experiment with solving problems without suffering all the costs and consequences. The end product of these assignments is usually forgotten; what’s important is the skills it gives you along the way.

If we were to design our own screenwriting course, what would it consist of? Well, we would probably focus on the areas where we are weakest (character and story development) then design some exercises to help us explore and strengthen those skills.

So this is the simple exercise I propose: If you are given any human role—fireman, doctor, teacher, street bum, etc.—you should be able to come up with a little conflict for this person to be engaged in that results in an entertaining 10-minute screenplay written in a day. If you did a lot of these exercises, you would have much better knowledge of character development and story conflict and could start thinking about bigger projects.

The exercise doesn’t necessarily mean you actually have to write the 10-minute screenplay, although I think that should happen at least a few times. You just have to think things through to the point where you could write the 10 minute screenplay if you wanted to.

I contend that there’s no point in attempting a 90-minute screenplay if you can’t distill the conflicts of the main character into a 10-minute one. If you can’t pull off the 10-minute show, you won’t be able to do the 90-minute one. 10-minute shows also allow you to experiment with a LOT of story ideas in a relatively short period of time.

If I throw out a role—say, “fireman”—you should be able to come up with a character-based conflict for that person, and resolve it within 10 minutes. Sounds challenging, but I think it can be done—for ANY character you can name.

You see, every character has his flaws that arise naturally from his social role, and with a little brainstorming you can see what they might be. For example, for a fireman, I can think of two potential flaws: (1) He’s more obsessed with keeping his fire engine clean than fighting fires, and (2) He may deliberately set fires himself to give his life more meaning. Each avenue leads to an interesting story.

The resolution comes when either (a) the character finally recognizes his own weakness and uses this knowledge to overcome his problem, or (b) at least we, the audience, finally understand what is going on.

The simplest case is (b): We see a fireman racing around putting out fires, but at the end of the film we realize that he’s the one setting the fires. In this case, we are the ones having the character transformation; the fireman isn’t. This avenue often works, but it’s kind of bland and one-dimentional.

The more satisfying scenario, however, is (a): Fireman obsessively sets fires but eventually has a revelation that prompts him to change his behavior, at least temporarily.

I said that every great film consists of the same conflict: Plainly motivated character encounters a mysterious force; eventually understands this force and, if possible, uses this knowledge to conquer his enemy. In (b) above, we the audience are the plainly motivated character and the fireman is the mysterious force who we eventually come to understand. In (a) above, the fireman is the plainly motivated character, who we understand from the beginning is a pyromaniac. The mysterious force is his own obsession, which he eventually comes to understand.

Think of the original Star Wars movie. What is the essential conflict there? It’s a naïve boy encountering the bigger world for the first time. He lacks confidence and takes himself a bit too seriously. In the end, however, he learns to “Trust the Force.” At a critical point in the conflict, he pushes his instruments aside and puts his faith in something different. All of the spaceship battles of the movie basically serve (or should serve) this one central conflict. The whole “Death Star,” in fact, was designed to serve this central conflict.

In Star Wars, it was a hokey conflict, not terribly deep, but it is one of the things we most remember about the movie: “Trust the Force.” The later movies eventually fell flat because they didn’t have this central unifying concept. Without this core exercise in character change, a movie becomes just a series of scene strung together without any overall meaning.

So are you ready to try this character exercise? Whenever you encounter someone playing a role, you should be able to say: (1) What the defects of this character may be, (2) what natural conflicts and quests arise because of these defects (propelling the movie along), (3) how to express these conflicts in concrete, filmable actions, and (4) what character change takes place to resolve these conflicts. You should then be able to write a satisfying 10 minute screenplay, or at least describe it.

Only when we can complete this exercise for ANYONE in ANY role are we ready to attempt a larger project.

Merging vs. Engulfment

In response to a blog posting today by Miss Model Behavior ("Why Are You So Sensitive?"), I posted the following response:
Kilroy here, from Las Vegas. By defining this as a male/female problem, I think MMB is missing the point. This isn't a matter of Mars vs. Venus but more of a fundamental human conflict: merging vs. engulfment. This is something that applies to all sexes equally: male/female, gay/straight, eunuch, celibate, etc. Males and females may have different ways of expressing it, but merging/engulfment is a basic conflict in all of us and is the main reason early romances don't usually work.

Let me give you the Cliff's Notes version. We are all the product of two warring forces: the "urge to merge" -- that is, the desire to join with someone else -- and the desire to be an independent and self-sufficient being. When you're alone and lonely, merging becomes your primary concern, and you tend to hopelessly idealize the other party. But once you start merging with someone real, idealism is quashed by reality, and the opposite inclination kicks in: "Oh my God, I'm drowning!" Hence, the desire to pull away.

It takes a great deal of maturity and self-knowledge to balance the two. It also takes time, in any relationship, to negotiate a balance, no matter how mature the parties may be.

Your opponent in this case may be a dick, but he's a gender-free dick expressing the same cycle we all go through: "Oh my God, I'm alone!" alternating with, "Oh my God, I'm drowning!" It's no mystery that most people haven't yet found a balance.

Tuesday, July 29, 2008

Screen Story #4: "Over There!"

My writing project today is a 9-minute screenplay...

"Over There!" (pdf file)

A tragedy in 1917 leads to a revelation in 1990.

The George M. Cohen song "Over There" is a key element in the film. For the lyrics of the song, see its Wikipedia entry. For an audio file of the song as I had it in my head, go to America's Story.

This is my 4th screenplay. For others, see index.

Sunday, July 27, 2008

Coyote vs. Roadrunner: Lessons for Screenwriting

Everything I know about character development I learned by watching Roadrunner cartoons.

Each character -- Wile E. Coyote and the Roadrunner – have their own motivations and obey their own distinct rules of behavior. Chuck Jones defined some of these rules when the cartoon was created.
  • The Roadrunner just wants to run down the highway. He won’t do anything aggressive to the coyote except by saying “Beep, Beep!”
  • The Coyote just wants to catch the Roadrunner. Unable to do it by speed alone, he calls on his wits and the products of the Acme Corporation to try to achieve his goal. He is ultimately defeated by his own intentions, thwarted by forces he doesn’t understand (physics, the Roadrunner).
When these characters interact, it is the purest form of what I call "existential story conflict" or "existential filmmaking."

Existential story conflict works like this: A protagonist with obvious goals (the Coyote) does his clever best to achieve these goals (through the use of Acme products) but he is thwarted by mysterious forces he doesn't understand (the Roadrunner and the laws of physics). Eventually, however, he does understand them (by experiencing the painful effects of his scheme).

In the cartoons, there is no character change. The Coyote "learns his lesson" by receiving the bad effects of his scheme, but he doesn't learn anything in the long term. In more complex films, the protagonist does change, by learning about both himself and his opponent.

An existential story is a voyage of discovery, driven by the protagonist's simple goal. The mysterious force is explored, and eventually the roots of its behavior are uncovered.

The whole story is based on a simple principle: the motivations of a character, while plain to them, may not be obvious to someone else. The other person has to discover these motivations by a series of experiments, which is what makes up the bulk of the story.

Examples:
  • In 2001, the astronaut Dave is the obviously motivated protagonist. He just wants to complete his mission. Hal 9000 is the mysterious force: He seems to want to kill Dave and his colleagues. When Hal sings "Daisy", we learn something about Hal's motivations: That he isn't just a killer computer but something of a grown-up child like the rest of us.
  • In Barton Fink, the title-named protagonist just wants to write a screenplay. His salesman neighbor seems to just want to help, but he turns out to be a mysterious force with more sinister motivations. The resolution comes when those sinister motivations are revealed.
  • In the Truman Show, Truman is the innocent protagonist, just trying to make sense of life. The mysterious force he is trying to understand is the TV show that has been created all around him. Eventually, he comes to understand that it is a TV show, and this allows his escape.
All of the great existential films are like this: A simple protagonist we can identify with is trying to make sense of mysterious forces. Those mysterious forces are eventually understood and turn out to be just as simple as the protagonist.

All these stories are essentially the same as Coyote vs. Roadrunner (or more precisely, Coyote vs. the World). The protagonist has simple motivations that power the course of the whole story. (Most of the running time of cartoons consist of the Coyote assembling his Acme devices.) The substance of the film is how the Coyote sets out to get the Roadrunner, but the surprise is how the opposing forces have different plans. The resolution comes when the Coyote eventually grasps the opposing forces -- usually by being whacked on the head by them!

Glenn's Best Relationship Photos

My best relationship photos are found on Facebook: temporary album, permanent album

Saturday, July 26, 2008

Renaissance Faire Photos: Escondido 2007

I am stunned by the quality of some of my own Renaissance Faire photos from about a year ago. Here are some photos from just one of the three I have attended, the Escondido Renaissance Faire in California in April 2007.

A selected album is available on Facebook: Escondido Renaissance Faire, April 2007

The complete albums of 100s of photos from this event are available on RoamingPhotos: Day 2, Day 4

Many more Renaissance Faire photos are found at RoamingPhotos.com

Baby's First Screenplays

Inspired by a filmmaker friend, I have written three short screenplays, just as an exercise. They're my first screenplays ever! (So there are bound to be some rough spots.)
  1. Gunderson Road. A vulture in the Mojave Desert encounters a curious sight. (My friend points out that I have given far too much camera direction.) There is a bit of an Area 51 connection to this one. The protagonist of the film is shown above. (6/25/08)
  2. Soul Ascension. Two missionaries prowl a suburban neighborhood for converts, only to become prey themselves. My favorite of the three! (6/29/08)
  3. Natasha. This is the first few minutes of a hypothetical full-length movie about a Soviet superheroine. (7/5/08)
Not bad for a beginner! I read a book on screenwriting once but never actually wrote a screenplay before. For the format, I just copied my friend's screenplays.


NOTE: For later screenplays, see here.

Best Song of All Time: "Houdini's Box" by Jill Sobule

My favorite song of all time is "Houdini's Box" by Jill Sobule. It is rather obscure, and I have never heard it played on the radio. You can listen to it for free on Rhapsody on their Jill Sobule page.

To me it's the perfect mix: simple voice, simple & compelling imagery, just enough accompaniment. What is the song about? I have no idea, but that's exactly the point: It's little mystery that you get something more out of every time you listen to it -- like all great songs.

The important elements of the lyrics --
  • Powerful
  • Ambiguous
  • Symbolic
  • Dangerous
The "danger" comes in the idea of being locked in a box underwater. It is a metaphor for drowning in a relationship. I think ALL great songs have this element of existential danger to them.

It resembles another favorite song of mine, "Hotel California" by the Eagles. What is the song about? Who the hell knows, but the imagery is so compelling that we try to figure it out every time. The song work and lasts forever because the mystery is both compelling and unsolvable. (The last thing we would want is for the songwriter to tell us what he was thinking when he wrote it; that would totally spoil the illusion.)

Sobule's song, I imagine, started with the words "Houdini's Box" and was built from there. It doesn't really have to "say" anything; it just has to leave you with haunting questions.

The ending is perfect, the way it leaves you hanging.

I've tried listening to Jill Sobule's other songs, but none can compare to this. The others, I think, get too wordy and specific; they don't remain lyrical and symbolic like this one. She's got a fantastically subtle voice, but she's just not putting it to good use.

What she needs is a good concept editor.

Friday, July 25, 2008

Gay Divorce


Relevant to yesterday's "Ban Gay Marriage" posting, here is an article in today's LA Times on Gay Divorce...

'They've given us no choice but to be married forever,' says a Rhode Island woman. Her state doesn't recognize gay marriage, and the state where she was wed limits divorces to residents.
(Los Angeles Times, 7/25/08. By Sue Horton. Keywords: same-sex marriage)

Sound Experiments

I haven't done much with sound editing, but I'd like to. As proof of the concept, here are two "sound experiments" I did for Family Court about two years ago. They demonstrate the capabilities of the Sony Sound Studio software I was using. Each is a little "song" of sorts lasting about a minute.

The first clip plays in the background of this page...


It demonstrates the cutting and pasting of sound clips. Be sure to click on the "backwards" link for the alternate version.

The second clip is a little story playing in the background of this page...


This was concocted entirely in the "studio" using background noises provided with the software.

One of my favorite jobs in the movie biz is "Foley artist" -- the person who provides the various environmental sounds of a movie.